Try the tool: Tire size comparison: check a new size against your stock tire

Off-road gear on Amazon

Sponsored

As an Amazon Associate, Off Road Freedom earns from qualifying purchases. See our affiliate disclosure.

Prices and availability were accurate when retrieved from Amazon and may change. Retrieved Nov 12, 2026.

What to compare on the best all terrain tires

The best all terrain tires for your truck or SUV depend on your size, your load and where you drive, and no list can pick for you. What a list can do is point to the facts that makers state and that you can check against a size. Those are the snow marking, the treadwear warranty and the sizes offered, plus whether your size is a metric (P) or light truck (LT) fit.

  • 3PMSF. The three-peak mountain snowflake marking means the tire met an industry snow-traction test. Confirm it for your size, because not every size carries it.
  • Treadwear warranty. The mileage the maker will cover, usually with conditions, exclusions and proration. Read the warranty for your size.
  • Sizes. Check that your size exists, and whether it is LT or P-metric. LT tires are built and rated differently from P-metric tires.
  • Intended use. All-terrain tires are a compromise. If you drive deep mud often, read all-terrain vs mud-terrain tires.

Before you pick a size, learn to read it: how to read tire size explains the code in the diagram below, and the tire size comparison shows how a new size compares with your stock one.

Off-road gear on Amazon

Sponsored

As an Amazon Associate, Off Road Freedom earns from qualifying purchases. See our affiliate disclosure.

Prices and availability were accurate when retrieved from Amazon and may change. Retrieved Nov 12, 2026.

The four tires side by side

Everything in the table comes from the maker's product page on the check date. Where a page gives a range, we give the range. We rank nothing and show no scores: we have not tested these tires.

Tire3PMSF on the maker's pageTreadwear warranty as statedSizesBest for
BFGoodrich All-Terrain T/A KO3Yes50,000 miles121 listedA wide size range
Toyo Open Country A/T IIIYesUp to 65,000 miles15 to 22 in rims, 165 listedA trial offer
Nitto Terra Grappler G3Yes70,000 miles on hard metric sizes, 55,000 on LT and flotation sizesStill adding sizesA long treadwear figure
Cooper Discoverer AT3 4SYes65,000 milesSee the maker's size listMostly pavement with trail days
Diagram of a tire sidewall with an example size code and a key: light truck, width in millimeters, aspect ratio, radial, wheel diameter, load index and speed rating.
Each part of a sidewall code means something different; the load index and speed rating are on the tire.

Our four picks and why we chose them

Each pick has a role, the facts the maker states, a note on who it is not for and a link to the page we read. Warranty terms have conditions: each maker's page says to read the full warranty, and so should you.

  1. Widest size list

    BFGoodrich All-Terrain T/A KO3

    Why we chose it: The maker's current all-terrain with the snowflake marking and a very wide size list.

    • 3PMSF (severe snow rated) on the maker's page
    • 50,000-mile mileage warranty
    • Standard limited warranty: defects for the life of the original usable tread or 6 years, whichever comes first
    • 121 sizes listed on the maker's page

    Not for: Drivers who want a long mileage warranty above all: other tires in this list state more miles.

    Checked 2026-11-12 on the BFGoodrich product page.

    Find BFGoodrich All-Terrain T/A KO3 on Amazon

  2. Best trial offer

    Toyo Open Country A/T III

    Why we chose it: A broad size range across 15 to 22 in wheels, with a trial offer.

    • Three-Peak Mountain Snowflake qualified for severe snow
    • Treadwear warranty up to 65,000 miles
    • 500 miles / 45 days trial offer on the maker's page
    • Sizes from 15 in to 22 in rims (165 listed in total)

    Not for: Anyone who needs a fixed warranty number for their exact size: the page says up to 65,000 and points to the warranty booklet.

    Checked 2026-11-12 on the Toyo product page.

    Find Toyo Open Country A/T III on Amazon

  3. Highest treadwear figure

    Nitto Terra Grappler G3

    Why we chose it: The highest treadwear figure on this list, with separate numbers for metric and LT sizes.

    • 3-Peak Mountain Snowflake rating
    • Treadwear warranty 70,000 miles on hard metric sizes, 55,000 miles on LT and flotation sizes
    • The maker calls it its best all-terrain tire
    • The maker is still adding sizes

    Not for: Owners of rare sizes: the size list was still growing when we looked, so check yours first.

    Checked 2026-11-12 on the Nitto product page.

    Find Nitto Terra Grappler G3 on Amazon

  4. Best for mostly-pavement driving

    Cooper Discoverer AT3 4S

    Why we chose it: Aimed at drivers who spend most miles on pavement and want snow-rated tread.

    • 3PMSF designation on the maker's page
    • 65,000 mi / 95,000 km treadwear warranty
    • The maker says actual mileage may vary by vehicle type or tire size and exclusions apply

    Not for: Heavy-rig owners wanting the most aggressive tread: this one is aimed at all-season, on-road use with trail ability.

    Checked 2026-11-12 on the Cooper product page.

    Find Cooper Discoverer AT3 4S on Amazon

Amazon buttons are affiliate links: we may earn from qualifying purchases, at no cost to you. Prices and stock change, so check the listing. See our affiliate disclosure and how we choose.

Choosing a size without guessing

A tire is a bad place to guess. Start with your stock size on the door-jamb placard or in the owner's manual, and make a short list of sizes you could fit. Then use the tire size calculator for the diameter, width and sidewall of each, and the comparison tool for the change in speedometer reading and clearance. We do not list stock tire sizes by model here, because the maker's spec page is the only source we trust for those.

Wheel width and offset matter as much as the tire. See the wheel offset calculator, and if you go much larger, read planning a suspension upgrade because lift, tires and gearing have to be planned together. The gear ratio calculator shows whether regearing is worth thinking about.

Pressure, repairs and care

Tires wear faster at the wrong pressure. Use the placard value as your starting point, check cold, and re-check after airing down. If you air down on the trail, follow how to air down safely. Carry the means to fix a flat: our plug kit picks and inflator picks list options by role. Rotate and inspect as your warranty requires, because mileage warranties often need records.